The PWHL draft order is literally just giving “me when I make shit up”
Vancouver Goldeneyes (won gold plan, we knew this ahead of time)
Seattle Torrent (2nd in gold plan standings)
PWHL Detroit (expansion team, random draw)
PWHL San Jose (expansion team, random draw)
PWHL Las Vegas (expansion team, random draw)
PWHL Hamilton (expansion team, random draw)
New York Sirens (3rd in gold plan standings, but got 0 points)
Toronto Sceptres (4th in gold plan standings, eliminated on the last day of the season)
Minnesota Frost (reverse playoff standings)
Boston Fleet (reverse playoff standings)
Ottawa Charge (reverse playoff standings)
Montréal Victoire (reverse playoff standings)
Table of Contents
The controversy
The most egregious part of this draft order is the fact that the Gold Plan teams Seattle, New York, and Toronto are separated in the draft order.
Lots of folks are upset that the expansion teams are choosing so high up in the order. I hear you. But honestly, if the new expansion teams had picks 2-5, and then the gold plan teams Seattle, New York, and Toronto picked 6-8, it still would have felt more fair to me.
What is the difference between Seattle and New York and Toronto? Maybe it’s the fact that Seattle actually earned some Gold Plan points, whereas New York and Toronto earned zero? Yet, Toronto was eliminated on the last day of the season and had no chance to earn Gold Plan points. Anyhow, using “0 gold plan points” as a criteria for separating the teams feels extremely arbitrary.
Some people have said that Seattle gets to pick second because they “need more help” than New York, but I would argue that New York needs a lot of help, considering they have never finished higher than second-to-last in the league.
I’m personally fine with the expansion teams being favored, but inserting them after Seattle feels extremely unfair to New York and Toronto.
The GMs only just found out about the draft order
You might be thinking that we, as the fans, only just found out about the draft order. Yet the reality is that even the PWHL GMs did not know the draft order until today! Pat Laprade did a great breakdown of why this was a huge issue for the PWHL teams themselves, fan engagement, and media.
What’s my take?
I am so happy that Torrent is picking second. I REALLY hope that Torrent drafts Laila Edwards, although a lot of people are assuming that they will choose Abbey Murphy. Yet, honestly it does feel very unfair to me that Torrent gets to pick second, while New York is literally picking seventh 😭
Detroit picking third will be iconic, considering that the draft is being held in Detroit, but it will do nothing to counteract the narrative that Detroit is being favored by the league.
Overall, this expansion process has felt extremely disorganized. If the draft order was released prior to expansion, I still wouldn’t have liked it, but it would have allowed teams, media, and fans to prepare much better.
Will the Knight trade still happen?
A trade between Detroit and Las Vegas for Hilary Knight could happen, but I doubt it will be for a first-round draft pick. Given that Detroit is picking third, they could draft either Abbey Murphy or Laila Edwards, who are probably worth more to them than Knight. Specifically, Abbey Murphy plays right wing, which is the same position as Knight. Laila Edwards is a right handed defender, and Detroit is already stacked at RD, with no LD, but I’m sure they can figure it out…
I can still see this trade going through, but Detroit will be more likely to trade a second round pick, or maybe Detroit trades the third pick for Vegas’ fifth pick? If the trade doesn’t go through then Hilary Knight will play a season in Las Vegas.
Submit a Question for my PWHL Draft Livestream with Kyle Cushman!

Join us for a livestream watch party of the 2026 PWHL draft on Wednesday, June 17, at 5PM EST / 2PM PST!
Read Kyle’s full PWHL Draft Rankings on his substack! You can also find Kyle on Twitter and Instagram.
Upgrade your subscription to attend monthly livestream watch parties! Support me so that I can continue making women’s hockey content. ($5 per month)
Paid subscribers will also receive a 365 Hockey Girl sticker and zine in the mail! 🎉
PWHL Expansion Phase 4
Phase 4 will conclude today (Monday, June 15). By the end of Phase 4, expansion teams will have reached 10 players total. View all of the latest news in my PWHL Expansion Live Tracker!
Reach 1.9K women’s hockey fans! Check out my media kit and reach out to me at [email protected]!
